sharpone2323's pick · Updated September 2026
Mr. Coffee Black Coffee Maker

For a simple drip machine that has to sit on a counter and get used without much thought, this kind of coffee maker is mainly for someone who wants an easy routine and a full pot when they need it. It also fits an office setup or a home kitchen where the appeal is more about consistency and timing than gadgets or special brew settings.
I have had this maker for 3 years now. It makes perfect coffee for the use case described here, and the timer feature is great. It is ready when I am ready for it, which is really the point of a machine like this. There is something useful about walking into the kitchen or the break room and finding the pot already waiting.
The main thing to check with a basic 12-cup machine is whether that size matches the way it will actually be used. A bigger carafe can be handy when more than one person drinks coffee, but it may feel like more than you need if you usually make just a cup or two. The glass carafe is also worth keeping in mind, since glass can be easier to see and pour from, while still asking for a little more care than a thermal pot.
The evidence here is straightforward and limited to what has been experienced: three years of ownership, good results from the coffee, and real value from the timer. That is enough to say the machine has held up as a practical daily tool, but not enough to make claims about every kitchen, every water type, or every brewing preference. If you want a no-frills coffee maker that does the basics and lets you set it ahead of time, this is the sort of product that can make sense.
It seems best for someone who wants coffee ready on a schedule and does not want to fuss with a lot of settings. The timer is the feature that stands out most here, and for the right person that alone can make the machine worth keeping on the counter. If your main question is whether it will fit into a steady, ordinary coffee routine, the answer from this usage is yes.
A small point to verify before buying is whether you prefer the feel of a glass carafe and a standard drip workflow over a more insulated or more customizable setup. That is less a flaw than a decision point. For a buyer who wants dependable timed coffee in a familiar format, this looks like a good fit.
Some Amazon links are affiliate links. sharpone2323 may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
See current price